If you own a US entity as a non-US resident, getting money from the entity to yourself is rarely as simple as a bank transfer. Different routes produce different tax outcomes, and routes that look interchangeable produce different filing obligations. The wrong choice creates US tax exposure that the right choice avoids.
Quick Answer
The five mechanisms are: (1) owner distribution from a pass-through, (2) salary as a W-2 employee, (3) contractor payment via 1099, (4) dividend from a C-Corp, (5) royalty for licensed intellectual property. Distribution and dividend depend on entity structure. Salary and 1099 depend on where the work is performed. Royalty applies only when the entity is licensing IP from you.
1. The Threshold Question
Before any payment is made, three facts decide the available options.
- Entity structure: disregarded LLC, partnership LLC, S-Corp (not available to non-residents), or C-Corp. The structure determines whether a payment is a distribution of the owner's own income or a separate transaction.
- Where the work is performed: services performed inside the US generally produce US-source income for the person performing them. Services performed entirely outside the US generally do not. The location of the work, not the location of the payer, drives US tax treatment for compensation.
- US tax residency status: non-resident aliens are taxed only on US-source income. Resident aliens are taxed on worldwide income. The substantial presence test can convert a non-resident to a resident without immigration changes.
If you have not yet confirmed your residency status or your entity classification, those questions come first. Our LLC Taxation guide covers the four classification options and what each means for owner payments.
2. Owner Distribution from a Pass-Through Entity
This is the most common mechanism for foreign-owned LLCs.
A disregarded single-member LLC is transparent for US income tax. Money in the LLC's bank account is already considered the owner's money. Transferring it to a personal account is not technically a payment. It is the owner withdrawing their own funds. No US payroll, no withholding, no separate income tax event at the moment of transfer.
The income tax obligation arises from the underlying activity, not from the distribution. If the LLC's activity produced ECI, the owner files Form 1040-NR and pays US tax at graduated rates regardless of whether the money was distributed. If the activity did not produce US-source income, distribution does not create one.
For a multi-member partnership LLC, the same principle applies but with a complication. Each owner is taxed on their allocated share of the LLC's income reported on Schedule K-1, whether or not the income was distributed. Distributions are not separate income events. Distributions in excess of the owner's basis can produce gain recognition, which is a separate analysis.
3. Salary as a W-2 Employee
Salary requires the owner to be a W-2 employee of the US entity, with all the obligations that creates: payroll tax registration in the relevant states, FICA and Medicare withholding, federal and state income tax withholding, quarterly Form 941, year-end W-2 issuance.
For a non-resident owner, salary creates a fundamental issue. Compensation for services performed in the US is generally US-source income, taxed as ECI on Form 1040-NR at graduated rates. Compensation for services performed outside the US is generally foreign-source and may not be subject to US tax at all.
If the owner is performing services in the US under appropriate work authorization, salary is straightforward but expensive. If services are performed entirely outside the US, paying salary through US payroll often creates US-source income that would not otherwise exist, and creates compliance costs that produce no business benefit.
S-Corp election is not available to non-resident owners. The reasonable salary requirement that applies to S-Corp shareholders does not apply to non-resident-owned entities.
4. Contractor Payment via Form 1099
If the owner provides services to the US entity from outside the US and does not want to be a US employee, the contractor route is often the cleanest.
The mechanic: the owner provides Form W-8BEN to the entity confirming non-resident status. The entity pays the owner as a foreign contractor. If services are performed entirely outside the US, the income is foreign-source and not subject to US withholding. If services are performed in the US, US-source rules apply and the income may be ECI subject to graduated tax.
Form 1042-S, not Form 1099, is the correct reporting form for payments to foreign contractors. The W-8BEN has to be on file before payment for the foreign-source treatment to apply. Without it, the entity is required to withhold at default rates on the assumption that the income is US-source.
This route requires careful documentation of where the work was performed. Travel days in the US during which work was conducted can convert otherwise foreign-source compensation into US-source income on a partial basis.
If you are setting up the payment structure for the first time and want to make sure the route fits your entity and residency, an international tax review runs the analysis before payments begin.
5. Dividend from a C-Corp
Dividends are available only when the entity is a C-Corp. They are not a pass-through mechanism.
A C-Corp pays US federal corporate income tax on its income at 21%. After-tax profits can be distributed to shareholders as dividends. For a non-resident shareholder, dividends are FDAP income subject to 30% US withholding at source, unless reduced by an applicable income tax treaty.
Most US treaties reduce the dividend rate to 15% for portfolio shareholders and lower (often 5% to 10%) for substantial corporate shareholders meeting an ownership threshold. Reduced rates require Form W-8BEN-E on file with the corporation before the dividend is paid.
The combined burden of corporate tax plus dividend withholding is what makes the C-Corp structure expensive for owners who plan to extract profits. For owners reinvesting profits in the business or building toward an exit through a stock sale rather than ongoing distributions, the structure works differently.
Our comparison of Delaware C-Corp vs LLC for foreign founders covers when each structure makes sense, including how owner payments factor into the choice.
6. Royalty for Licensed Intellectual Property
If the owner personally holds IP (software, trademarks, patents, copyrights) and licenses it to the US entity, the entity can pay royalties for the license.
Royalties are FDAP income subject to 30% US withholding at source by default, often reduced under a tax treaty. Withholding rates for royalties vary more than dividend rates by treaty and by the type of royalty (industrial, copyright, know-how).
This route requires a real licensing arrangement with proper documentation: a written license agreement at arm's-length terms, IP that genuinely exists and was developed by the owner, royalty rates supported by transfer pricing analysis. The IRS scrutinizes royalty arrangements between related parties closely. A bare assertion that the owner holds IP, without underlying substance, does not produce a defensible position.
Where it works: the owner developed the underlying IP before the US entity was formed and has documented ownership. Where it does not work: the IP was developed inside the US entity using its resources, then transferred to the owner without consideration, then licensed back.
7. Side-by-Side Comparison
The mechanics of each route at a glance:
| Route | Available For | US Withholding | Owner Filing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner distribution | Disregarded LLC, partnership LLC | None on transfer itself | 1040-NR if ECI |
| Salary (W-2) | Any entity with US payroll | Federal + state on wages | 1040-NR for US-performed work |
| Contractor (Form 1042-S) | Any entity | 0% if foreign-source w/ W-8BEN | 1040-NR if US-performed |
| Dividend | C-Corp only | 30% (or treaty rate) FDAP | Generally none unless underwithheld |
| Royalty | Any entity, requires real IP | 30% (or treaty rate) FDAP | Generally none unless underwithheld |
8. Common Mistakes
- Setting up US payroll for self when work is performed abroad: creates US-source ECI that would not otherwise exist. Adds compliance costs without business benefit.
- Treating distributions as deductible business expenses: owner distributions are not deductions. They are after-tax movements of the owner's own funds.
- Not getting W-8BEN on file before contractor payments: default 30% withholding applies until the form is on file. Recovery requires filing a return and waiting six months or longer for refund.
- Claiming royalties without underlying IP substance: the IRS treats sham royalty arrangements as disguised distributions. Penalties can include the disallowed deduction at the entity level plus accuracy-related penalties.
- Mixing routes within the same year without clean documentation: an owner who took some payments as distributions and others as contractor fees needs documentation supporting why each was treated as it was. Inconsistent characterization without basis invites IRS reclassification.
If you are still working out whether your activity creates ECI in the first place, our post on ECI vs FDAP covers the framework that determines how each payment route is taxed.
This post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute professional tax, legal, or accounting advice for your specific situation. Reading this post does not create a CPA-client relationship. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. If you would like advice tailored to your situation, consult a qualified tax professional, including through the services offered on this site.